There used to be a time when Annie Lennox was the one and only stand out British Female Solo Artist. Throughout the majority of the 90’s and early 00’s it seemed that every year she was either nominated or won herself the Brit. Then something changed. The UK was inundated with new talent. Dido had her time, Kate Nash, Lily Allen, Amy Winehouse, KT Tunstall and Duffy all took turns at the title as the undisputed Queen of emotive warbling.
Although Laura Marling won Best Female this year it is unashamedly Adele who currently sits upon the throne, but now in 2011 she is already staving off another wealth of pretenders to her crown. One of the strong favourites is the hotly tipped, BBC championed, Clare Maguire who releases her debut album – Life After Dark.
And its the influence of Annie Lennox where our journey begins, the album kicking off with a mood defining heartbeat intertwined with an soaring string accompaniment and a vocal seemingly plucked straight from the Eurthymics songbook. You instantly feel like this is something you have heard before. Like Lennox, Maguire has one of those incredible voices that can be close, soft and personal one moment and sweepingly anthemic the next but it’s not put to good use in a formula that disappointedly doesn’t change throughout the album 13 tracks.
Maguire’s vocal brings elements of gothic pop, not seen since Shakespeare’s Sister, to an otherwise frustratingly bland, generic mainstream pop template, and its these fleeting moments of edginess that provide some of the album’s highlights, a style one’s wishes acclaimed producer Fraser T Smith had done more with.
Next track Shield and the Crown, an obvious future single, sounds exactly like the Florence and the Machine’s ‘Dog Days are Over.’ joe public are sure to lap this up but it seems like its yet another life affirming ‘paint by numbers’ inspirational ballad. Tracks such as the haunting I Surrender, most recent single ‘Last Dance’ and the beautiful Bush-esque ‘Happiest Pretenders’ show that she can definitely stand her ground, it’s just a shame the production seems to have squeezed the life out of what seems to be some extremely accomplished song writing from a genuine talent.
It’s as if they have taken every successful ingredient, Florence and the Machine-esque raw epic wailings coupled with more modern Ellie Goulding sparkly electro dance sensibilities to create a album ripe for a Radio 2 playlist. Sure they are doing what is required these days but to this degree?
Legend has it that Maguire forged her way via myspace, one of her songs attracting 500,000 plays which pricked the ears of the record companies. It just feels that the album has perhaps gone through many a boardroom and every standout part of Clare has been worn down to produce a list of radio friendly tunes. In all fairness that’s where the album succeeds, almost every track could easily be released as a single, not because of their strength but because they are simply variations of the same theme.
Only This is Not the End, dripping in regal Celtic charm, provides us with an indication of what she is capable when left alone. Its certainly not the End for Clare Maguire but you feel this beginning could have been so much more….
6 out of 10.
http://bbmlive.com/music-news/clare-maguire-light-after-dark.htm
James